Troubleshooting CPUBalance: Fixes for High Load and Thermal ThrottlingCPUBalance is a userland daemon designed to manage CPU frequency governors and power profiles dynamically, aiming to balance performance, responsiveness, and power consumption. When configured correctly, it can smooth out sudden load spikes and reduce unnecessary CPU boost that leads to higher temperatures and battery drain. However, misconfiguration, system-specific interactions, or hardware limitations can cause high CPU load and thermal throttling instead of preventing them. This article walks through diagnosing and fixing common CPUBalance issues, with practical steps and examples.
How CPUBalance works (brief overview)
CPUBalance monitors CPU load and adjusts governor parameters or switches power profiles to reduce aggressive boosting behavior. It can interact with kernel interfaces (cpufreq, CPU governors, thermal zones) and higher-level power frameworks (e.g., TLP, powerd). Its policy decisions typically aim to:
- Reduce unnecessary frequency boosts on short bursts of load.
- Favor energy-efficient frequencies under light-to-moderate load.
- Allow higher frequencies only when sustained load requires them.
Misbehavior usually stems from incorrect tuning, conflicts with other power managers, kernel bugs, or hardware thermal design limits.
Symptoms that indicate CPUBalance-related problems
- Persistent high CPU frequency and elevated temperatures at idle or light load.
- Frequent thermal throttling (sustained drops in CPU clocks to avoid overheating).
- Poor responsiveness or sudden lag during normal use.
- High system load averages caused by CPU-bound user processes that shouldn’t be heavy.
- Conflicting power managers fighting over frequency governors (e.g., CPUBalance vs. distro power profiles).
Step 1 — Collect diagnostic data
Before changing settings, gather logs and runtime state so you can compare before/after and revert if needed.
Commands to run (run as a normal user; use sudo where required):
- Current CPU governor and frequencies:
grep . /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu*/cpufreq/scaling_governor cat /proc/cpuinfo | egrep "model name|cpu MHz" - Per-core frequencies and maximums:
watch -n 0.5 "cat /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu*/cpufreq/scaling_cur_freq" - CPUBalance status/logs (location depends on distro; common places):
- Systemd journal: sudo journalctl -u cpubalance -n 200 –no-pager
- /var/log/cpubalance.log (if configured)
- Thermals and throttling:
sensors # from lm-sensors watch -n 1 "cat /sys/devices/virtual/thermal/thermal_zone*/temp" dmesg | grep -i -E "throttle|thermal|cpu" - Running processes causing load:
top -b -n 1 | head -n 20 ps -eo pid,ppid,cmd,%cpu --sort=-%cpu | head -n 20 - Power managers that may conflict:
systemctl list-units --type=service | egrep "tlp|power|cpubalance|thermald|laptop-mode"
Save the outputs to a file for later comparison:
mkdir -p ~/cpubalance-diagnostics # example: sudo journalctl -u cpubalance -n 200 --no-pager > ~/cpubalance-diagnostics/cpubalance-journal.txt Step 2 — Check for conflicts with other power managers
Common conflicts:
- thermald, TLP, powertop auto-tuning, distribution power profiles, laptop-mode-tools, and desktops’ power daemons may attempt to control governors or thermal policies. When multiple daemons fight, governors can flip rapidly and produce higher power usage.
What to do:
-
Temporarily stop other power managers to see if behavior changes:
sudo systemctl stop tlp.service sudo systemctl stop thermald.service # Also disable distro-specific power profiles if present -
Re-run diagnostics (temperatures, frequencies, load). If stopping other services fixes it, decide which service should manage CPU policy and disable the others.
Step 3 — Adjust CPUBalance configuration
CPUBalance uses configuration files to define governor preferences, thresholds, and behavior. Typical settings include sample intervals, boost suppression thresholds, and per-cpu or per-cluster rules.
Locate and back up config:
- /etc/cpubalance/cpubalance.conf (path varies by package/distro)
Key parameters to consider:
- Sampling interval: too-large intervals can be slow to adapt; too-small can cause oscillation.
- Boost prevention thresholds: lower thresholds reduce boosting on short bursts.
- Per-cluster tuning: treat high-performance cores (big) and efficiency cores (little) differently.
Example changes (illustrative — adapt to your distro file format):
- Increase sample interval from 50ms to 100–200ms to avoid reacting to microbursts.
- Lower allowed boost window so short spikes don’t push frequencies to max.
- Set explicit governor per cluster: ondemand/powersave for little cores, schedutil for big cores.
After edits, restart:
sudo systemctl restart cpubalance sudo journalctl -u cpubalance -n 200 --no-pager Step 4 — Tune kernel governor and scheduler interaction
Modern kernels expose governors like schedutil, performance, ondemand, and ondemand-like helpers. CPUBalance may favor schedutil for scheduler-driven scaling. But scheduler settings also matter:
- Ensure cpufreq driver supports the chosen governor.
- Check kernel boot parameters that affect cpufreq/thermal behavior (e.g., intel_pstate=, pstate=, or energy_perf_bias).
- For Intel: check intel_pstate status:
cat /sys/devices/system/cpu/intel_pstate/status cat /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu*/cpufreq/scaling_available_governorsIf intel_pstate is active, use its recommended knobs (e.g., energy_performance_preference) rather than trying to force a different governor.
Step 5 — Address thermal throttling directly
If overheating persists even after governor tuning, investigate cooling and hardware limits.
- Clean dust from cooling fins/fans; ensure vents are unobstructed.
- Reapply thermal paste on laptops/older desktops if temperatures are unusually high.
- Monitor which workloads trigger throttling — some workloads (e.g., heavy single-threaded bursts) generate heat faster than cooling can cope.
- Examine thermald (if present) for aggressive thermal profiles that may throttle unnecessarily:
sudo systemctl status thermald sudo cat /etc/thermald/thermal-conf.xml - Consider undervolting (carefully) where supported; undervolting reduces power draw and heat. Use vendor-recommended tools or kernel interfaces; on laptops, check for BIOS options.
Warning: undervolting can destabilize a system if misapplied. Test thoroughly.
Step 6 — Kernel and microcode updates
Sometimes the root cause is a kernel bug, driver interaction, or outdated CPU microcode.
- Check for and apply available kernel updates for your distribution.
- Update CPU microcode packages (intel-microcode, amd64-microcode).
- Review distribution changelogs for regressions in cpufreq or pstate drivers.
Step 7 — When high load is caused by runaway processes
CPUBalance can’t fix a misbehaving process. If a specific process is causing sustained CPU load:
- Identify and analyze it:
ps -eo pid,cmd,%cpu --sort=-%cpu | head -n 10 strace -p <pid> -f -s 200 -o ~/cpubalance-diagnostics/strace-<pid>.txt - If the process is unnecessary, kill or adjust its configuration.
- For background tasks, use nice/ionice or cgroups to limit CPU share:
sudo cgcreate -g cpu:/limited echo 50000 | sudo tee /sys/fs/cgroup/cpu/limited/cpu.cfs_quota_us sudo cgclassify -g cpu:limited <pid> - Consider systemd slices and CPUQuota= for services to constrain CPU use.
Step 8 — Use logging and monitoring to verify fixes
After making changes, keep logs and monitor for a while:
- Enable verbose logging for CPUBalance if available.
- Use stress tests to confirm thermal behavior under load:
sudo apt install stress-ng # or distro equivalent stress-ng --cpu 4 --timeout 300s --metrics-brief - Watch temperatures and frequencies during test:
watch -n 1 "sensors; cat /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu*/cpufreq/scaling_cur_freq" - Compare before/after logs saved in ~/cpubalance-diagnostics.
Quick checklist (summary)
- Collect diagnostics: governors, cpufreq, logs, temps, processes.
- Check conflicts: stop other power managers temporarily.
- Adjust CPUBalance config: sampling, boost thresholds, per-cluster rules.
- Tune governor/scheduler: use appropriate governor (schedutil vs intel_pstate).
- Fix thermals: clean, reapply paste, check cooling, consider undervolting carefully.
- Update kernel/microcode: rule out driver/firmware bugs.
- Control runaway processes: use cgroups, nice, systemd CPUQuota.
- Monitor after changes: run stress tests and collect logs.
When to seek further help
- If thermal throttling continues after trying the above, collect your diagnostics directory (logs, outputs from commands listed) and consult your distribution’s support channels or the CPUBalance project issue tracker. Provide exact kernel versions, CPUBalance version, and copies of your cpubalance config and journal entries showing governor changes and throttle messages.
Troubleshooting CPUBalance often reveals broader system tuning needs: balancing daemon configuration, kernel governor choice, and hardware cooling. Methodical diagnostics plus small iterative changes will usually resolve high-load or thermal-throttling problems.
Leave a Reply